Current EU Bioenergy Policy
Currently, EU bioenergy policy can be found under the climate and energy package. This package consists of several pieces of legislation, each of them forming a piece of the puzzle to tackle climate change.
The goal is that by 2020 the European Union will:
- save 20% of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions compared to 1990
- cover 20% of its energy consumption from renewable energy sources
- improve energy efficiency by 20% (this is a non-binding goal)
The Renewable Energy Directive (RED) and Fuel Quality Directive (FQD)
The RED is one of the most stringent parts of the package. It sets two targets that Member States need to attain by 2020.
The first target states that 20% of the overall EU energy consumption by 2020 needs to come from renewables. In this case we are mainly talking about electricity, heating and cooling.
The second target is that 10% of the overall EU energy consumption in transport needs to come from renewables by 2020. This mainly refers to transport fuels, but it can also be reached through electricity, etc.
The RED basically asks Member States to set up a system, which they need to describe in their National Renewable Energy Action Plans (NREAPs), to attain these numbers, which often happens through subsidies, tax exemptions and consumption mandates.
The Member State Action Plans have now shown that biomass will supply more than half of the EU’s renewable energy by 2020 and more than 8.3% (hence almost the entire 10%) of the transport target. This will mean a steep rise in the use of biomass for energy and that growth comes with a risk of serious socio-environmental costs.
The demand is also likely to exceed the sustainable level of biomass supply. Moreover, this policy is paid for by the European taxpayers. For the transport policy alone this means 6 billion EUR in subsidies for mainly unsustainable biofuels.
The RED has sustainability criteria for raw materials going into biofuels and bioliquids. All other use of biomass has no sustainability requirements at all. Moreover, the criteria for biofuels is not stringent enough or has not yet been fully implemented. The current sustainability criteria also does not secure GHG savings, since it doesn’t recognize the emissions caused by Indirect Land Use Change (ILUC).
Another part of the package is the FQD. This directive tackles the issue of clean and dirty fuels. By 2020, fuel suppliers need to show that they are mixing cleaner fuels in their fuel mix so that they are decarbonising their fuels with 6%.
This directive aims to tackle both dirty fossil fuels and the mixing in of biofuels that are saving emissions. The FQD does not just set blunt consumption mandates, but allows different types of fuels to compete not only on production costs but also on their GHG savings.
Attempts to deal with sustainability criteria for biofuels and bioliquids
Neither biofuels nor bioliquids, although there are sustainability criteria for both the RED and the FQD, take ILUC into account. BirdLife believes it is key to take up ILUC factors in the sustainability criteria, while at the same time putting in place a strong cap on the use of all land based biofuels. To avoid repeating mistakes, the advanced biofuels (made from waste and residues) should get stringent sustainability criteria.
(No) attempts to deal with sustainability criteria for biomass
For biomass used in the energy sector for heating, cooling or electricity production the RED doesn’t require any kind of sustainability criteria. The directive still obliged the European Commission to follow the development of biomass use and report on the need to extend the sustainability scheme.
The Commission’s report in 2010 stated that it didn’t see a need to extend the scheme to biomass but encouraged Member States to introduce their own sustainability schemes for bioenergy. This was despite the fact that 90% of the respondents of a related consultation were in favour of a sustainability scheme for all types of biomass.
Since then, Member States have not shown much interest to follow the Commission’s recommendation. As the use of biomass has sharply grown, more and more questionable practices in its use have been reported. The pressure for the Commission to make a proposal on sustainability criteria has therefore steadily increased.
Other parts of the Climate and Energy Package
Furthermore, the package includes legislation on the Emission Trading Scheme (ETS) and the Effort Sharing Directive. The former is a tool for reducing industrial greenhouse gas emissions through a cap and trade system. The Effort Sharing Decision establishes binding annual greenhouse gas emission targets for Member States for the period 2013–2020. These targets concern emissions from most sectors not included in the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), such as transport (except aviation), buildings, agriculture and waste.